Best Italian Restaurants

Published: January 1, 2024

When you think about food in Shelby County, you probably think about soul food; pork chops, gravy, and biscuits. But did you know Shelby County is also home to some of the best Italian food in the state? 

Best Italian Restaurants

Keep reading to find out where you and your family should stop next time you’re craving the satisfying taste of some rich Italian food, right here in your own backyard. 

Bellinis Ristorante 

First up on the list is Bellinis Ristorante which stands out as the city’s premier Italian Infused Steakhouse. If you’re looking for a dining experience that combines the excellence of perfectly hand-cut steaks, house-made pastas, exquisite seafood, and classic Tuscan Italian dishes, then Bellinis is your destination. The ambiance at Bellinis is nothing short of spectacular, with an inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements its mouthwatering menu.

At Bellinis, the art of grilling is elevated to a whole new level, as each steak is carefully selected and cooked over a wood-burning grill to perfection. Whether you’re craving a juicy steak, succulent veal, or the freshest seafood, Bellinis has you covered. Their commitment to quality extends to their extensive wine selection, allowing you to pair your meal with the perfect touch. If you’re in the mood for something sweet, don’t miss their weekly dessert specials that add a delightful finishing touch to your dining experience.

Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a culinary adventure, Bellinis offers a taste of Italy that’s second to none in Shelby County. Discover the magic of Italian-infused cuisine and savor the flavors of Bellinis – where every dish is a masterpiece waiting to be savored. Your quest for a remarkable dining experience ends here at Bellinis!

Cafe Trentuno

This next spot is super special. Cafe Trentuno in Pelham is about as classically American-Italian as they come. Guests will feel right at home in this cozy little pizza joint right off Pelham Parkway. You’ll feel like you traveled to Tuscany as you enjoy the delicious food and take in the beautiful murals of the old country that cover each wall of the cafe. 

The menu is loaded with classic Italian favorites like manicotti, pizzas, calzones, and many more! You can even order pizza by the slice which means you can mix and match and have the ultimate Italian feast when you dine at Cafe Trentuno! They even have extra toppings so you can customize your orders to make your pizza just how you like it. 

All that Italian food is sure to make you thirsty, so be sure to ask about their beer and wine selection. They have classic reds that go great with their award-winning food, and domestic and premium beers. In short, there’s literally something for everyone. Next time you head in, be sure to keep an eye on their board to see what daily specials are up for grabs, and bring your appetite!

Bertolone’s 

The next must-visit restaurant on our list is an absolute show-stopper. Bertolone’s Classic Italian Restaurant in Calera is the product of a decade of dedication to perfection. A family business, the owners of Bertolone’s know Italian food. The recipes come straight from the heart (and kitchen) of the current owner’s parents, and you can taste the love in every bite. 

The family atmosphere is evident by pictures that line the walls at Bertolone’s commemorating the years spent serving others and preparing excellent, heartwarming food for all those who enjoy it. The menu is loaded with Italian classics, plated beautifully, like lasagna, classic spaghetti and meatballs, and many more. 

A full cocktail bar and wine list contains the perfect pairings for all your Italian favorites. You can also reach out for catering, events, and hosting parties! You’ve got to see why we can’t stop thinking about Bertolone’s. Head in today and you’ll immediately feel like you’re part of the family. 

SanPeggio’s Pizza

Next up on our list is SanPeggio’s Pizza. Although there are a few locations, the one in Chelsea is one of Shelby County’s best pizza parlors! Explore the tastes of Tuscany at SanPeggios. The pizza selection has something for everyone. Stick to the classics with their award-winning pepperoni pie, or branch out for something a little less mainstream like their famous Hawaiian punch pizza!

Pizza isn’t the only thing that’s turning heads and pleasing taste buds at SanPeggio’s, though. Try some of their delectable pasta dishes like ziti, lasagna, and many more! Also, don’t forget to try their famous chicken wings. Available in many flavors and styles, the wings are the perfect complement to their pizza pies. And when you’re done, save room for their amazing desserts!

Amoré Ristorante 

Shelby County is fortunate to have a gem like Amoré where you can consistently enjoy the exceptional quality of food, service, and atmosphere. Located on Highway 280 in Birmingham, this restaurant has some of the most authentic Italian food in Shelby County and maybe even the state! For almost 20 years, Amoré has been serving up Italian classics, artistically created and beautifully plated, bringing smiles to faces without fail. 

The menu isn’t from your average mom-and-pop Italian kitchen. Delicious Italian classics from each region of Italy dominate the carefully curated menu. Try their veal scallopini, pork chops, and plenty of pasta dishes! The seafood on the menu is the freshest catch possible. Explore options like lobster fra diavolo, or dishes featuring beautiful, fresh jumbo lump crab.

With a full bar and countless wine options, you can relax and enjoy a drink while you wait for your award-winning dishes to arrive. The perfect date night spot, Amoré has something on the menu for any Italian craving. Come explore their menu and take in the beautiful atmosphere at Amoré Ristorante, you’ll be glad you did. 

A Taste Of Italy In Shelby County

While you may not often think about Italian food when you think of places to grab a bite to eat in Shelby County, this list should help jog your memory next time you’re having a carb-loaded craving! This list is far from exhaustive, there are tons of options out there. So, whether it’s a casual night in a small cafe or a special occasion at a higher-end Italian kitchen, you can rest easy that your cravings are covered!

Related Content

Mountain Biking At Oak Mountain State Park

With all the rugged terrain around Shelby County, it’s no surprise there is no shortage of places to mountain bike. For thrill-seekers, the opportunities to mountain bike in Shelby County are seemingly endless. One of the best places in the state for mountain...

A Hiking Weekend In Oak Mountain State Park

Oak Mountain State Park is a great place to escape for the weekend and hike some amazing trails. It is one of the best places to go hiking in Shelby County, and it is the perfect place for those who wish to go off the grid for a couple of days.  A Hiking Weekend In...

Kick Off Summer With Memorial Day in Shelby County

It’s no secret that Memorial Day is the official kickoff to summer, and that’s no different in Shelby County! With plenty of Shelby County events to choose from and other ways to celebrate, you can get your summer started right. Whether you decide to attend an...

24 Hours In Harpersville, AL

Across Shelby County, there are certain places that take you back in time to the small-town Alabama of days past. One of those places is Hapersville. The town itself predates both Shelby County and the State of Alabama. Today, the simplistic, small-town feel of...

Excitement In Old Town Helena

Newly located in the historic old town of Helena, Alabama, Buck Creek Bed and Breakfast invites you to embark on a quintessential Southern getaway in Shelby County. Here you'll discover a haven where every moment is infused with the warmth of hospitality and the...

Anna Jones

A Guide To Oak Mountain State Park With Anna Jones

Hello, adventurers! We had the pleasure of sitting down with Anna Jones, the event coordinator at Oak Mountain State Park, and learned all about the park's fascinating history, exciting activities, and why you should plan your next adventure here. Join us as we...

XTERRA Oak Mountain

Oak Mountain State Park in Pelham is proud to be this year’s host of the XTERRA North American Championship! This triathlon event is held nationwide and features some of the best athletes from around the world competing in a grueling, rugged outdoor environment....

Shelby County Springtime Bucket List

Shelby County, Alabama is an amazing place to live and visit, and residents here enjoy lots of year-round activities. Shelby County is consistently ranked as one of the fastest-growing counties in Alabama, and this is a testament to how wonderful this place truly...

24 Hours in Columbiana, AL

The town of Columbiana boasts some exciting attractions, places to grab a bite to eat, and many scenic places to enjoy the natural beauty of Shelby County. Keep reading to find out all the best places you have to visit the next time you’re in Columbiana.  24 Hours...